Thread: why this is NOT a perpetuum mobile

1. i was thinking on balance when i came with this design

of course i know is not a perpetumm mobile but dont see why, why this shouldnt work since the water arm thought with the same weight than mercury so both remain in balance is always more to the right of the wheel

in other words, in this wheel, cog will always be permanently to the right of the winge of the wheel with which a momentum appears, whats wrong with this?

edit:

dont get me wrong i dont want to build a perpetumm mobile but an stable inverted pendulum and this seems a very odd and intersting unbalance

2.

3. What is a winge? Where is the cog? Your drawings are terrible.

Yeah, sorry man, but they are.

5. sorry my bad hope this shows my doubt clearer:

as you can see on the one hand both colums are in balance by aplying density*gravity*height of column

but this moves the center of gravity off the center of the wheel with which theres an arm

6. Loook here burtleburtle.net/bob/physics/whythere.html -

there is no perpetual motion.
get drawing lessons

7. i said first i dont intend this to be a pm

i just wonder what happens here since:

on the one hand both columns are in balance being mercuries 1 cm high and waters 13 cm

on the other hand cog falls off the center with which theres an arm

so if you say it doesnt move thanks a lot, thats exactly what i intend to have a stable cog NOT UNDER THE VERTICAL of the axle

8. Originally Posted by Harold14370
What is a winge? Where is the cog? Your drawings are terrible.
hahah I love it! short and to the point

I agree lux your drawings are truely awful, please don't become an artist, also whats a perpetumn mobile? and i'm also having rather alot of trouble understanding what you say in your first post

Lux what I would take from this thread is that no one really knows, as shown very clearly by fizzlooney, when people in this forum can't answer something, they tend to throw up various facts about the subject while completely avoiding the question, instead of answering your question specific to your diagram, he's simply told you pmm's are impossible and hyperlinked you somewhere to prove it

I havn't come across a mercury-water pmm before and frankly have no idea how it's supposed to work, however I can hazzard a few guesses as to why it doesn't work
firstly it's possible that nature simply balances out the inbalance in the wheel that would give it perpetual motion, I don't know how it would, but I know nature does things like that sometimes so it's a possible cause

secondly and far more likely, the wheel is not a pmm and instead simply transfers energy around the wheel, making it last for a much longer time that appears normal (much like a newtons cradle) without external factors like friction it would continue to spin indefinately but the initial energy is expended on these external forces over time

 Bookmarks
Bookmarks
 Posting Permissions
 You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts   BB code is On Smilies are On [IMG] code is On [VIDEO] code is On HTML code is Off Trackbacks are Off Pingbacks are Off Refbacks are On Terms of Use Agreement