I don't for one second think that a God is required for morality, but is there any such thing as 'absolute morality'?
People claim that without God, morality would just be subjective, but if there is a God, how exactly how does that make morality absolute?
Is it because whatever God says is moral, and if so how are we making that judgement, and couldn't that just be its opinion?
In the case of there not being a God, wouldn't I need to rely on consequentialism to determine between right and wrong? And in a hypothetical case where the pleasure a rapist gets is more than the suffering the victim endures, such that there is a net gain of happiness, under that alone, it would make it moral. But I don't for one second think it's moral, but then I'm relying on how I feel about it to inform my morality, and that can't always lead to me the moral answer either.
In the end, are we just left with subjective opinion on what is moral, as informed by the consequences and intent, as well as the emotional response it produces in us?
As you can see, I'm really lost.