
Originally Posted by
Harold14370

Originally Posted by
Mazhara
How could you or me term any idea as "your own idea" or "my own idea". Why we forget that we were taken out of the womb of mother in a state that we did not have knowledge of anything. Nothing is of your own. It is self deception not accepting the truth.
That is a very excellent observation, and one which you did not need a religious text to make. We do come out of the womb without any knowledge.
We have to learn from our parents and others what the purpose of life is. You learned that it is connected to Islam, somebody else learned that it is connected to Christianity, or Hinduism, or something else. We are influenced by things we read, what our friends think, and so forth. Our particular life experience, temperament, mental abilities, etc., combine to give each of us a unique perspective. This is what I mean when I refer to your own or my own ideas. Now, what do you mean by self deception, or what truth do I need to accept?
Will you please note the inherent contradiction therein. How can I call what was thrust upon me-whether Islam, Christianity, Judaism, hinduism, budhism, etc etc--as my idea?
When would I become of age to develop an idea about which I could honestly say "it is my idea-my conclusion"? You please tell me the criteria and the source, first to form that idea of my own, and then to evaluate it.