Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: The Ambiguity of our Situation

  1. #1 The Ambiguity of our Situation 
    Forum Ph.D.
    Join Date
    Feb 2007
    The Ambiguity of our Situation

    Those who know say that Kierkegaard (circa 1840) was a psychoanalyst without fear of being laughed at because he knew that the scoffers are uninformed. Few sapiens have such courage born of self-confidence. The noted psychologist Mowrer said “Freud had to live and write before the earlier work of Kierkegaard could be correctly understood and appreciated.” Such, is genius.

    Wo/man is a union of polar opposites; self-consciousness and physical body. It is thus “the true essence of man”. “Leading modern psychologists have themselves made it the corner stone of their understanding.”

    The evolution into self-consciousness from self-satisfying ignorance inherent in animal nature had one great tragedy for wo/mankind, which is anxiety or dread. It is our very humanness which produces anxiety--dread of death. This anxiety results from the ambiguity of our situation and our inability to overcome such an ambiguity. This ubiquity of ambiguity drives us into the creation of a virtual world in which to live. Self-consciousness cannot be denied, we cannot disappear into a state of vegetation, we cannot flee dread; we can only create delusions--a virtual reality.

    The task of the sciences of psychology, psychoanalysis, sociology, and anthropology are to discover the strategies that humans use to avoid anxiety. How do we function automatically and uncritically in our virtual world and how do these strategies deprive us of true growth and freedom of action?

    Today we talk about ‘repression’ and ‘denial’; Kierkegaard, the pioneer, called these same things “shut-upness”. He recognized the ‘half-obscurity’ in which wo/man lives her life, he recognized that man recognizes the truth of ceremony, how many times to bow when walking past the altar, he knows things in the same way that a pupil uses ABC of a mathematical expression but not when it is changed to DEF. “He is therefore in dread whenever he hears something not arranged in the same order.”

    Shut-upness is what we today call repression. Kierkegaard recognized a “lofty shut-upness” and a “mistaken shut-upness”. It is important that a child be reared in a lofty shut-upness, i.e. reserve, because it represents an ego-controlled and self-confident perception of the world.

    Mistaken shut-upness, however, results “in too much blockage, too much anxiety, too much effort to face up to experience by an organism that has been overburdened and weakened in its own controls…more automatic repression by an essentially closed personality”. Good is openness to new possibilities and evil is closed to such possibility.

    Shut-upness is called, by Kierkegaard, “the lie of character”. “It is easy to see that shut-upness eo ipso signifies a lie, or, if you prefer, untruth. But untruth is precisely unfreedom…the elasticity of freedom is consumed in the service of close reserve…Close reserve was the effect of the negating retrenchment of the ego in the individuality.”

    This ‘lie of character’ is developed by the infant’s need to adjust to the world. This unfreedom becomes mistaken shut-upness when the character becomes too fearful of the world to open itself up to its possibilities. Such individuals become ‘inauthentic’; they are not their own person; they follow a life style that becomes automatic and uncritical, they become locked in tradition. This infant grows up becoming the ‘automatic cultural-man’.

    “Devoid of imagination, as the Philistine always is, he lives in a certain trivial province of experience as to how things go, what is possible, what usually occurs…Philistinism tranquilizes itself in the trivial”.

    Quotes from “The Denial of Death”; Pulitzer Prize winner for nonfiction by Ernest Becker.

    Reply With Quote  


  3. #2  
    Forum Freshman
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Your points are undoubtedly valid in some cases but do not worry to much. Many great minds I'm sure came from repressed family culture. The imagination of an individual does not necessarily follow the building blocks of their experiences. As surely as the fact images/ideas do not equal the previous lines of thought that spawned them. They always have the possibility to grow exponentially and leap great distances out and away from their constituent factors.

    Some would say that being repressed causes revolutionary out-leaps, hunger drives ambition, and surely an enclosed mind/individual can be catalysed and cause the catalysation of others solely by their mental struggling.

    Maybe less people achieve intellectual openess in a society dominated by discipline but what of the possibility of enhanced mental attitude developing out of the few that's brains/physiologies actually respond favorably to the mental strains caused by stress. Look at the effects of autism on the brain in its specialization and abilities that develop in multiple directions that have opened up new directions in experimentation research (boy who sees numbers). If this is applied in a diluted form, a specialization in say Imagination without limitation could indeed come forth from many different backgrounds. I myself believe that the individual can -bar fear for their life (completely different to fear of chastisement)- make the choices -given talent- to move their minds to the frontier.

    Peace and freedom does of course aid an overwhelming move forward in the development of mankind but the individual doesn't always follow the model?

    Demons flourish amongst the streaming minds-eye,
    they feed on the scum that grows from rocks,
    thoughtful detritus from the airy garden falling,
    covering all of us in the sins of others.
    We don’t stop, we feel their fiery temperament,
    We enjoy it, we use it, we need it we think.
    But out of the scum comes the shining ones,
    covered in ash, they have fallen from the future,
    thought far-seeing, prescient pathfinders,
    As alluring as the demons ever were.
    Reply With Quote  

Posting Permissions
  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts