# Thread: algebra fix

1. I want to know the results of following equations.
x2 + x +1 = y
In the above equation for 1 value of x there is 1 value of y. But for 1 value of y there are three values of x as it then becomes a 3rd degree equation.
1.If we go on substituting values for the variable x we get 1 value of y.
2.If we substitute values for y we get 3 values for x.
Aren't case 1 and case 2 supposed to yield the same result?  2.

3. Originally Posted by parag29081973 I want to know the results of following equations.
x2 + x +1 = y
In the above equation for 1 value of x there is 1 value of y. But for 1 value of y there are three values of x as it then becomes a 3rd degree equation.
1.If we go on substituting values for the variable x we get 1 value of y.
2.If we substitute values for y we get 3 values for x.
Aren't case 1 and case 2 supposed to yield the same result?
Um, that is a 2nd degree equation?  4. Originally Posted by parag29081973 I want to know the results of following equations.
x2 + x +1 = y
In the above equation for 1 value of x there is 1 value of y. But for 1 value of y there are three values of x as it then becomes a 3rd degree equation.
1.If we go on substituting values for the variable x we get 1 value of y.
2.If we substitute values for y we get 3 values for x.
Aren't case 1 and case 2 supposed to yield the same result?
As the previous comment noted it is quadratic in x, not cubic. In general functions don't have to be 1-1. y = x^2 is even simpler.  5. True.

It might just be worth pointing out that it usual to make a distinction between polynomial forms i.e. expressions like (where the are scalar and the are drawn from any commutative ring and the subscripts on the former are indices and the superscripts on the latter are exponents)

and polynomial functions which have the same form but a perfectly well-defined domain and co-domain.

Example the distinct forms and each define the same function (the identity ) when , the ring of integers mod 2 but not (necessarily) otherwise

It may also be worth pointing that , if we take the highest exponent with non-zero coefficient to be the degree of a polynomial form (or function - doesn't matter which) then any degree polynomial as exactly values of that satisfy . These are called the "roots" or "zeros" of a polynomial form or function. This is known as the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra. (proof non-trivial!)

The polynomial in the OP accordingly has 2 roots. Try to find them if you dare, but I don't advise it - you'll freak!!  6. Originally Posted by Guitarist The polynomial in the OP accordingly has 2 roots. Try to find them if you dare, but I don't advise it - you'll freak!!
That's interesting Guitarist, in an imaginary way.

In the standard quadratic form the equation is , so a equals 1, b equals 1 and c equals 1.

The quadratic roots can be obtained by solving with a, b and c all equal to 1.  7. Originally Posted by Laurieag That's interesting Guitarist, in an imaginary way.
Ha ha - I assume you are referring to something like the following.......

Using a recipe related to yours, but slightly more general, I got that the 2 roots of are which (unless I messed up a sign somewhere - my usual failing) works quite nicely Note the imaginary unit, which leads me to the following......

A ring element that is the root of some polynomial (with rational coefficients) is called an "algebraic number", otherwise it is called a "transcendental number". Algebraic numbers are, in general, complex numbers - I go further: if an algebraic number does not "contain" the imaginary unit, we simply note that the Real numbers are a sub-set of the Complex numbers and Bingo!

You may not like the idea that the monster above is a number, but tough - you can see it is if you do the calculation (to prove it is the root of the OP polynomial)  8. Originally Posted by Guitarist Using a recipe related to yours, but slightly more general, I got that the 2 roots of are which (unless I messed up a sign somewhere - my usual failing) works quite nicely
Hi Guitarist,

I get a slightly different answer of and although they are equivalent if you mean .

first root = and the second = Further, in the equation , the square of each of the roots gives the other root and both roots multiplied together gives 1 (If I've got the signs straight). = , = and Whoever coined the term 'imaginary unit' certainly had a good imagination.  9. Originally Posted by Laurieag ... and both roots multiplied together gives 1 (If I've got the signs straight).
Surely that can't be right in general, what is the product of the roots of x^2 - 4 = 0? You dropped out c/a.

In any event a good way to look at this equation is that if x^3 = 1 then

x^3 - 1 = (x-1)(x^2 + x + 1) = 0

One root is x = 1, and the other two are the roots of the second factor, the subject of the thread. So these numbers are the complex cube roots of 1. If you graph them on the plane you'll see why the square of each of the non-real roots is the other one. And you'll also see why the real and imaginary parts of the roots are the sine and cosine values associated with the 30-60-90 triangle except for the signs.  10. Originally Posted by parag29081973 I want to know the results of following equations.
x2 + x +1 = y
In the above equation for 1 value of x there is 1 value of y. But for 1 value of y there are three values of x as it then becomes a 3rd degree equation.
1.If we go on substituting values for the variable x we get 1 value of y.
2.If we substitute values for y we get 3 values for x.
Aren't case 1 and case 2 supposed to yield the same result?
The answer to a question could be yes or no, but there are endless questions that will have yes as the answer. Your logic is being questioned. Yes or No?  11. Originally Posted by someguy1 Surely that can't be right in general, what is the product of the roots of x^2 - 4 = 0?
That's why I specified the equation given in the OP. a, b and c equal 1 as well as both roots multiplied by each other.

Further, in the equation   Bookmarks
 Posting Permissions
 You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts   BB code is On Smilies are On [IMG] code is On [VIDEO] code is On HTML code is Off Trackbacks are Off Pingbacks are Off Refbacks are On Terms of Use Agreement