1. Hello community, firstly I wish you a Merry Christmas since it's the 2nd day of Christmas celebration.

Then I've got a question:

When I want to differentiate a function with more than 1 variable, then, for the total differential, I need to do the following:

Let f(x1, x2, ....., xn) be a function of n variables. Then

Df/Dx1 + Df/Dx2 + ... + Df/Dxn = df/d(x1,...,xn)

(while D stands for the partial derivative symbol).

Why is it NOT

sqrt [(Df/Dx1)² + ... + (Df/Dxn)²] ???

Since, when I consider it in a geometrical sense, for example in 2 dimensions,
then I've got the change in x-direction and at the same time in y-direction.
Now these changes would be, as far as I know, added vectorically, i.e.
sqrt ((dx)² + (dy)²) , given a Euclidean distance between two points.

Could somebody explain to me where my mstake is, please? And further, one could also choose still other metrics or norms, which would yield yet other formulas.

Thanks a lot   2.

3. Originally Posted by mastermind
Hello community, firstly I wish you a Merry Christmas since it's the 2nd day of Christmas celebration.

Then I've got a question:

When I want to differentiate a function with more than 1 variable, then, for the total differential, I need to do the following:

Let f(x1, x2, ....., xn) be a function of n variables. Then

Df/Dx1 + Df/Dx2 + ... + Df/Dxn = df/d(x1,...,xn)

(while D stands for the partial derivative symbol).

Why is it NOT

sqrt [(Df/Dx1)² + ... + (Df/Dxn)²] ???

Since, when I consider it in a geometrical sense, for example in 2 dimensions,
then I've got the change in x-direction and at the same time in y-direction.
Now these changes would be, as far as I know, added vectorically, i.e.
sqrt ((dx)² + (dy)²) , given a Euclidean distance between two points.

Could somebody explain to me where my mstake is, please? And further, one could also choose still other metrics or norms, which would yield yet other formulas.

Thanks a lot It is neither.

See discussion of the derivative in several variables here. http://www.thescienceforum.com/A-question-28302t.php

In the case you have posed the derivative at a point is an nx1 matrix whic in your notation would be [Df/Dx1, Df/Dx2, ... , Df/Dxn ]  Bookmarks
 Posting Permissions
 You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts   BB code is On Smilies are On [IMG] code is On [VIDEO] code is On HTML code is Off Trackbacks are Off Pingbacks are Off Refbacks are On Terms of Use Agreement