# Thread: Question about the Color of Stars.

1. In the eighth episode of the TV show Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey, they talked about stellar spectra and their relationship with surface temperatures. Afterwards, I recalled that different characteristics of stars are summarized in the so-called Hertzsprung-Russell diagram:

(taken from ESO)

However, why are some colors missing on the x-axis of this diagram? Why can stars apparently not have a greenish or purple-like color?

2.

3. Originally Posted by Cogito Ergo Sum
However, why are some colors missing on the x-axis of this diagram? Why can stars apparently not have a greenish or purple-like color?
Have you every seen anything green hot? I think the constraint is in the black-body spectrum, noting that the x-axis is temperature.

4. Well, stars DO burn green. Our plants reflect that light as evidence. Perhaps it is down to our ability to perceive certain colors of light?

5. Originally Posted by KJW
Have you every seen anything green hot?

I cannot name something that has a high temperature whilst simultaneously appearing greenish.

Originally Posted by KJW
I think the constraint is in the black-body spectrum, noting that the x-axis is temperature.

Are you implying that the temperatures for purple and green would imply surface temperatures too cold for stars?

6. Originally Posted by Cogito Ergo Sum
Originally Posted by KJW
I think the constraint is in the black-body spectrum, noting that the x-axis is temperature.
Are you implying that the temperatures for purple and green would imply surface temperatures too cold for stars?
No. I'm suggesting that the shape of the black-body spectrum is such that at any temperature where one might expect it to be green, the amount of red or blue would be too large for it to actually be green.

7. Originally Posted by Flick Montana
Well, stars DO burn green. Our plants reflect that light as evidence. Perhaps it is down to our ability to perceive certain colors of light?
I think Cogito Ergo Sum was referring to light that appears green rather than light that contains green.

8. Originally Posted by KJW
Originally Posted by Flick Montana
Well, stars DO burn green. Our plants reflect that light as evidence. Perhaps it is down to our ability to perceive certain colors of light?
I think Cogito Ergo Sum was referring to light that appears green rather than light that contains green.
What I'm saying is that it is perhaps our ability to perceive light in that part of the spectrum which is affecting the color. Do our eyes better detect radiation in certain bands of the spectrum? Green appears white, purple appears blue, etc?

9. Curious About Astronomy: Why aren't there any green stars?
You're on the money. This site suggests that it is because of the sensitivity of our eyes and the way we perceive colour.
Our sun burns at the right temperature to emit yellow-green light as its peak output, but it's also emitting light across the rest of the spectrum with a fairly even distribution across the visible part. Our eyes happen to interpret this combination of wavelengths as "white".

Black body emission isn't going to give a distribution of wavelengths narrow enough around the green part of the spectrum to allow our eyes to pick it out. This site illustrates it pretty well. Blackbody Radiation

10. Originally Posted by Flick Montana
What I'm saying is that it is perhaps our ability to perceive light in that part of the spectrum which is affecting the color. Do our eyes better detect radiation in certain bands of the spectrum? Green appears white, purple appears blue, etc?
While it's true that the human eye has different sensitivities to different wavelengths, I think it's more likely that the narrowness of the green region and the broadness of the black-body spectrum would prevent a temperature that appears distinctly green rather than progressing from red to yellow to white as the temperature is increased.

11. Originally Posted by KJW
Originally Posted by Flick Montana
Well, stars DO burn green. Our plants reflect that light as evidence. Perhaps it is down to our ability to perceive certain colors of light?
I think Cogito Ergo Sum was referring to light that appears green rather than light that contains green.

Yes, that is what I meant.
My question is now solved, thanks to member Karsus.

 Bookmarks
##### Bookmarks
 Posting Permissions
 You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts   BB code is On Smilies are On [IMG] code is On [VIDEO] code is On HTML code is Off Trackbacks are Off Pingbacks are Off Refbacks are On Terms of Use Agreement